Hydrology and Earth System Sciences www.hydrol-earth-syst-sci.net 1027-5606 1607-7938 13 7 2009 10.5194/hess-13-1299-2009 http://www.hydrol-earth-syst-sci.net/13/1299/2009/ http://www.hydrol-earth-syst-sci.net/13/1299/2009/hess-13-1299-2009.html http://www.hydrol-earth-syst-sci.net/13/1299/2009/hess-13-1299-2009.pdf 1299 1305 2009-07-24 Comment on "Biotic pump of atmospheric moisture as driver of the hydrological cycle on land" by A. M. Makarieva and V. G. Gorshkov, Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 11, 1013&ndash;1033, 2007 A. G. C. A. Meesters A. J. Dolman L. A. Bruijnzeel Faculty of Earth and Life Sciences, VU University, Amsterdam, The Netherlands In their paper "Biotic pump of atmospheric moisture as driver of the hydrological cycle on land", Makarieva and Gorshkov (Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 11, 1013–1033, 2007) derive from "previously unstudied" properties of atmospheric water vapor, the existence of a hitherto unknown "evaporative force". From this, a novel physical principle is deduced, according to which low-level air flows from regions with weak, to regions with strong evaporation. As such, natural forests are claimed to "suck in" moist air from the ocean, a process labeled the "biotic pump of atmospheric moisture". <br><br> This commentary focuses on the physical foundations of the Biotic Pump Theory (BPT). It is shown that the "evaporative force" on which the theory is built, is not supported by basic physical principles. The problem of moisture transport and its dependence on vegetation cover considered by Makarieva and Gorshkov is certainly important, but cannot be solved along the lines proposed by them. Bannon, P. R.: Hydrostatic adjustment: Lamb's problem, J. Atm. Sci., 52, 1743–1752, 1995. Bruijnzeel,~L A.: Hydrological functions of tropical forests: not seeing the soil for the trees?, Agr. Ecosyst. Environ., 104, 185–228, doi:10.1016/j.agee.2004.01.015, 2004. Costa,~M H.: Large-Scale Hydrological Impacts of Tropical Forest Conversion, in: Forests, Water and People in the Humid Tropics, edited by: Bonell,~M. and Bruijnzeel,~L A., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 590–597, 2004. Dill,~K A. and Bromberg,~S.: Molecular driving forces, Garland Science, New York, 2003. Dolman,~A J., Silva Dias,~M A F., Calvet, J-C., Ashby,~M., Tahara,~A S., Delire,~C., Kabat,~P., Fisch,~G F., and Nobre,~C A.: Meso-scale effects of tropical deforestation in Amazonia: preparatory LBA modelling studies, Ann. Geophys.-Italy, 17, 1095–1110, 1999. Dutton,~J A.: The Ceaseless Wind, an Introduction to the Theory of Atmospheric Motion, Dover Publications, New York, 1986. Gedney,~N. and Valdes,~P J.: The effect of Amazonian deforestation on the Northern Hemisphere circulation and climate, Geophys. Res. Lett., 27(19), 3053–3056, 2000. Henderson-Sellers,~A., Dickinson,~R E., Durbidge,~T B., Kennedy,~P J., McGuffie,~K., and Pitman,~A J.: Tropical deforestation – Modeling local-scale to regional-scale climate change, J Geophys. Res., 98(D4), 7289–7315, 1993. Holton,~J R.: An Introduction to Dynamic Meteorology, 2nd edn., Academic Press, New York, 1979. Lamb, H.: Hydrodynamics, 6th edition, Dover, New York, 1945. Landau,~L D. and Lifshitz,~E M.: Course of Theoretical Physics, 6, Fluid Mechanics, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1987. Lydolph, P. E.: Climates of the Soviet Union. World Survey of Climatology, volume 7, Elsevier, Amsterdam-Oxford-New York, 1977. Makarieva, A. M. and Gorshkov, V. G.: Biotic pump of atmospheric moisture as driver of the hydrological cycle on land, Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 11, 1013–1033, 2007. McEwan,~M J. and Phillips,~L F.: Chemistry of the Atmosphere, Edward Arnold, London, 1975. Moore,~N., Arima,~E., Walker,~R., and Ramos da Silva,~R.: Uncertainty and the changing hydroclimatology of the Amazon, Geophys. Res. Lett., 34, L14707, doi:10.1029/2007GL030157, 2007. Nobre,~C A., Sellers,~P J., and Shukla,~J.: Amazonian deforestation and regional climate change, J Climate, 4, 957–988, 1991. Roy,~S B. and Avissar,~R.: Impact of land use/land cover change on regional hydrometeorology in Amazonia, J Geophys. Res., 107(D20), 8037, doi:10.1029/2001JD000662, 2002. Salati, E. and Vose, P. B.: Amazon Basin – A system in equilibrium, Science 225, 129–138, 1984. Silva Dias,~M A F., Rutledge,~S., Kabat,~P., Silva Dias,~P L., Nobre,~C., Fisch,~G., Dolman,~A J., Zipser,~E., Garstang,~M., Manzi,~A O., Fuentes,~J D., Rocha,~H R., Marengo,~J., Plana-Fattori,~A., Sá,~L D A., Alvalá,~R C S., Andreae,~M O., Artaxo,~P., Gielow,~R., and Gatti,~L.: Cloud and rain processes in a~biosphere atmosphere interaction context in the Amazon Region, J Geophys. Res., 107(D20), 8072, doi:10.1029/2001JD000335, 2002. Tennekes,~H. and Lumley~J L.: A~First Course in Turbulence, The MIT Press, Cambridge MA, 1990. Tijm, A. B. C. and Van Delden, A. J.: The role of sound waves in sea breeze initiation, Q. J. Roy. Meteorol. Soc., 125, 1997–2018, 1999. Van Delden, A.: Linear dynamics of hydrostatic adjustment to horizontally homogeneous heating, Tellus, 52B, 380–390, 2000. Van Kampen,~N G.: Stochastic Processes in Physics and Chemistry, North Holland Publishing Company, Amsterdam, 1983. Van der Molen,~M K., Dolman,~A J., Waterloo,~M J., and Bruijnzeel,~L A.: Climate is affected more by maritime than by continental landuse change: a~multiple-scale analysis, Global Planet. Change, 54, 128–149, 2006. Von Hann,~J.: Lehrbuch der Meteorologie, Verlag von Christian Hermann Tauchnitz, Leipzig, 1915. Wallace,~J. M. and Hobbs,~P V.: Atmospheric Sciences, an Introductory Survey, Academic Press, Orlando FL, 1977. Walter,~H.: Die Vegetation der Erde in oeko-physiologischer Betrachtung, Fisher, Jena, 1964. Walter,~H. and Lieth,~H.: Klimadiagramm Weltatlas, Gustav Fisher, Jena, 1967. Werth,~D. and Avissar,~R.: The local and global effect of Amazon deforestation, J Geophys. Res., 107(D20), 8087, doi:10.1029/2001JD000717, 2002.